cfiadw [prologue]
Sep. 20th, 2021 07:05 amprologue
before we start i'd like to welcome you to my brand new dreamwidth!! while i get used to how it works and the fact that i have a form of typing more than 240 characters at once at my disposal, i'll be focusing, for now, on these revision commentaries as i work my way through my fics! i hope you're even just a smidge as excited as i am!
the plan is, for your sakes and my own, to only include passages from the fic in question that i edited or have something to say about; some of these monster chapters are like 9k apiece and i don't plan on making you guys sort through my own commentary and then a million more words you've probably read before heh. but if in future commentaries you guys want me to put in the entire chapter please let me know, especially if maybe you've yet to read the fic and just wanna check out my commentaries and want context! i'm still deciding how i want to format this as a whole but! bolded portions will denote an edit/change that's been made!!
tw: as always, this fic deals in depth with themes of abuse (emotional/psychological, minor physical, implied sexual), manipulation, gaslighting, etc., and the resulting trauma. as such, i'll be discussing such themes in my commentary, especially as the fic reaches its climax. so if that in any way is triggering for you, i would highly suggest not reading. or, at the very least, please be careful.
let's go let's goooo!
I'm editing this fic the way I began writing it; sitting alone in the dark, keyboard lit only by the brightness of my screen and the flickering of the candles on the windowsill (spiced apple scents, because it might be 90 degrees still but fall is here!). My classical music playlist is on, partly so I can focus without words in my head - partly to settle into the vibe and ~aesthetic~ "catching fire in a devil's whisper" has. Before I even start reading, I remember how utterly thrilled I was to begin writing this story. Technically the third Seventeen fic I ever started, it came, as many of you know, after SVT's appearance at the 2020 Golden Disk Awards. At one point each of them wore a gorgeous masquerade mask and fancy suits, and my sister immediately decided someone (me) needed to write a Phantom of the Opera AU.


I, a fan of the musical ever since I saw the movie years and years ago (and then the musical itself in Las Vegas lmao), of course jumped at the chance and we threw the movie on to plan.
From the start, we knew we wanted to "update" it, so to speak, for a more modern way of thinking. Casting choices were decided before the overture was finished; deciding the Big Three was the easiest. Mingyu as Phantom might seem Really Weird and Perhaps A Bit Shocking but my reasoning for "casting" for AUs is simply that: it's a role they're playing in this story. Like a movie. My sister and I cast Mingyu as Phantom as an homage to the ehhh decent portrayal of Phantom that we grew up with; Mingyu is tall and devastatingly handsome the way Gerard Butler was in 2004 and, as an actor, could do it well, we like to think (ofc you all know i am DYING to see seokmin play the role on stage hhhhh). Plus, the Gyuhan dynamic is just.......... Really Really Good. So then with Mingyu as Phantom and Jeonghan as Christine it was Obvious to us that Seungcheol would be Raoul and from there, the rest of it fell into place. Chan as Meg; Wonwoo as half Madame Giry, half oc; Seungkwan as the incomparable Carlotta (who deserves So Much better), Seokmin and Soonyoung as Firmin and Andre was, I think, the pinnacle of our cast (what I would Pay to see BooSeokSoon perform "Prima Donna"...).... I mean, I adore this musical and each of its characters so to imagine my favorite people as them....

Ever since then, "catching fire in a devil's whisper" has been my most favorite fic of mine. My favorite to write, to plan, to edit, to think about....
[The title is an adaption of lyrics from a song by Mino (i honestly forget which one!).]
[Jeonghan is alone when he wakes up.]
One reason I love this fic so much is because of how anxious and scared Jeonghan is in it, which sounds AWFUL but let me explain; as someone who struggles with anxiety I found it so easy to write in his panic attacks, his moments of dread, and they honestly helped me, in some way, come to terms with my own. Always trying to better my writing, when I noticed I was feeling panicky I'd stop and think "hey, how am I feeling right now? How would I describe this?" and the panic would lessen.
[And besides, the sensations cease as soon as Jeonghan sits up and listens for the soft sounds of a fountain pen scratching on paper down the hall and then a smile will touch his face. Every time. And this morning is no exception. He sits against the headboard, blankets pooling around his thighs, and just listens. He can picture Seungcheol at his desk, the window in front of it wide open to let in as much light as possible. Curly hair falling into his eyes the way it did when he was twenty years old - and he'll stop writing every few minutes to brush it back with a light huff. A glass of water beside him, increasingly untouched the more he writes, the deeper into his work he gets. From here, the sound of his pen is gentle, comforting - everything about Seungcheol is comforting, Jeonghan has come to learn - and it helps the panic. He focuses on it until his breathing returns to normal, until his heart stops echoing through his body. He focuses on it until he feels ready to begin his day.]
At the risk of sounding vain, this has to be one of my favorite iterations of fic Jeongcheol ever. They go through so much - best childhood friends who are then separated by forces beyond them; to be reunited a decade later, at the tender age of twenty, and realize they're falling in love only to have that be threatened, once again, by something that wants to tear them apart so badly. They are full of love and grief and nostalgia for each other, for friends, for family, even, to some degree, for enemies - and just thinking about them spending the rest of their lives together.... hey okay, I really love this jc so much.
[Jeonghan sighs once more and heads down the hall to his husband’s study without so much as fixing his hair or changing out of his bedclothes. There would be no point in doing so, he decided long ago; Seungcheol has seen him at his lowest point and still adores him. Where he might have doubted such love years before, Jeonghan is older now, wiser now; too much has happened to prove to him that he can trust Seungcheol with the deepest, even worst, parts of himself. And he takes these little moments of trust where he can, moments he once thought he would never have with anyone. He enters the study, looking the epitome of sleep, and greets Seungcheol with a kiss to his scarred cheek, rubs his knotted shoulders until he sets down his pen.]
At this point in his life, twenty years since everything happened, Jeonghan is still dealing with the trauma forced upon him. It was something I always wanted to see the musical/movie touch on, but all we ever get to see of any aftermath is Raoul at the opera house auction forty or fifty years later, Christine simply a beloved memory... but it's obvious in his first words, spoken to the papier mache monkey thing the Phantom had {"a collector's piece indeed / every detail exactly as she said... / will you still play when all the rest of us are dead?"} that what happened in that single year (or less, depending on which timeline you subscribe to) had such a profound effect on him... I always wondered how Christine dealt with it as she grew older. Of course, my fic is darker and the character of the Phantom is less redeemable (which shouldn't be possible but hey, Phantom was written and composed in the '80s lmao...), which means more trauma...
Throughout the fic, we are reminded of how much, how deeply, how foolishly at times, Seungcheol loves Jeonghan. Ignoring very real threats from a very real man, surviving several attacks with physical and emotional scars, and ultimately scheming for said very real man's downfall to save his love - down to the moment he begs Jeonghan to let him die if it means Jeonghan will be free. Seungcheol is the epitome of unconditional, young, and heroic love in this role, so much so that I feel sometimes Jeonghan's equally as sweet, as pure love gets a bit lost in the mix. However, we see it clearly here in this soft morning and that's why this prologue is so important to me. Jeonghan loves Seungcheol just as much as Seungcheol loves him. He always has.
[“Love,” he whispers, reaching for Jeonghan with hands that do not tremble, that have never trembled. No, they’ve always held Jeonghan so close, so steady. Even in his darkest moments. So he trusts them now, just like he did back then, and entwines his fingers with his husband’s. “They’re tearing down the opera house this week.”]
The amount of love and trust between these two... hhhh they're so romantic.
[So with a heavy breath and words that sound more courageous than he feels, he murmurs, “You’re right. I’m - I’m tired of it all. I just… I hope it works. I want to feel like myself again.”]
I could spend thousands of words discussing the way Jeonghan's trauma has changed who he is as a person in this fic. But it would break my heart to do so.
["I'm ready," he whispers."]
yes you Are!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and so are we....
I always find controversial writer things amusing, but the never-ending feud of "prologue vs no prologue" gets me Going. Some argue that they're unnecessary and convoluted - but I've never thought so, and I don't think so with this fic. Telling this story as a story - that is to say, as Jeonghan's thoughts, as Seungcheol's thoughts, as Wonwoo's and even Junhui's, as they remember what happened during that year - always felt so natural to me. It's also an homage to the novel, published in 1909, which was written as an investigative report "told" presently to the reader. Because of all of this, I'll love this prologue forever, I think.
I don't have many thoughts as I reach the end of it, but the few I do have mirror Jeonghan's words: I'm ready. Chapter one, shall we?